BluePrintX

Photography should be about picture-making. That is, after all, why we get into it in the first place (well, most of us). This blog is for photographers, people passionate about making photographs, who want to share ideas and concepts, approaches and attitudes. And yes, there will, from time to time, be gear stuff. Oh, and by the way, while you can download and share this blog, all the material on it is copyrighted. All rights reserved, etc.

Tuesday, March 28, 2006

Who needs PhotoShop anyway?



Kia ora tatou:

Good morning, everybody. Last night I had the singular good fortune to talk to a small photographic group in northwestern Christchurch. The group has only been going for a year now, but there is considerable enthusiasm and interest in photography.

One member of the group, who has been following Blueprintx for some time, commented that sometimes, what is discussed here is quite-goes over my head is the word he used, and that it would be nice if there were some simpler stuff. At the end of my talk, the discussion turned to working with digital. This lady has only just got a digital camera, and is having difficulty with the basics. For her, downloading, archiving and storage of images, let alone editing, are challenge enough. It is easy to be somewhat for us ‘experts’ to be superior/supercilious, when you meet a beginner at this level. She commented that it would be really nice to see some of the really basic stuff put there for people like her.

So for the lady at the for Burnside photographic group, whose name I never learned, here are some very important but often overlooked basics to digital photography. In fact, I can feel a wee series of posts coming on. A sort of digital primer, really. Let’s begin by stomping on a myth.


There seems to be some sort of preconception out there that unless you're using PhotoShop, you really haven't arrived as a digital photographer, that you must learn PhotoShop before you can do any sort of significant digital photography.

Bollocks.

PhotoShop is the 18-wheeler of image editing programs. If you've just got your learners license on a Nissan March,, being thrown the keys to a B-train, and then being told to drive to the other end of the country is a bit of an ask. Using a big rig to buy the groceries at the supermarket is pure overkill. The point I'm trying to make here, is that there are programs out there, that will do a similar job, as well, if not sometimes more efficiently.
Crystal ball time: II would predict that once Adobe Lightroom is released, sales of CS2 will slump. Remember that PhotoShop was never designed for photographers anyway. It was originally aimed at prepress people and designers. In a sense, it is becoming a piece of bloatware. Adobe, however, seem to have caught onto this, and are now developing a product specifically fo digital photographers. If you're thinking of buying CS2, or CS3, when it is released in late 2007, I would hold off, and consider Lightroom instead.

So what are the alternatives to Photoshop?

Try, Paintshop Pro-fraction of the price, and every bit as good. (In some cases, better).
Alternatively, download the GIMP. Heavy duty, but that the best possible price-free!
If you want a simple program for downloading and renaming, try Picasa. Again, a free download.
If you are Mac, use iPhoto. The latest versions are really good.
And why haven’t I mentioned the manufacturers’ software?
Approach with caution!
Some are really good and some simply awful (Camedia software has been bad for my PC- but the cameras are really good). the only manufacturer's software I have had any joy with is what came with my Sony R-1.
I am interested in software you have used and enjoyed. There are already a number of suggestions in the comments on this post. feel free to add to them.
Ka kite ano.

8 Comments:

Anonymous Anonymous said...

I totally agree with your comments on Photoshop, that its not the "be all", and "end all".May I add that I have found spending time with like minded "nuts" helps one's understanding of a new Digital camera and/or Photoshop,(or some Image viewer). This is certainly a positive outcome of belonging to a group of like minded people. If I could be so bold as to advertise the Nature Photography Society,(based in ChCh).Our strength is our regular weekends away, totally focussing on photography.Good images, great people, a little wine for purely medicinal purposes of course.

Tue Mar 28, 04:36:00 pm GMT+12  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

As one of those present last night may I again say thank-you for all that you shared.

I know exactly where you are coming from regards photoshop. When I got my first digital 3 years ago it was my first port of call because I was told it was essential. 3 years of crashing through the gears in the B-train I am still no further along than "auto adjust" this and "crop" that. Thankfully the new generation of software has finally cottoned on the the real needs of the average photographer - KISS all the way. My only worry is Adobe is going to anticpate the slump in CS3 sales and price Lightroom to make up for it i.e. too high. Never mind, there is always Kazaa......

Tue Mar 28, 06:28:00 pm GMT+12  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Hi Tony
Great post

Last Friday I did a three hour digital photography workshop with some nine or so senior net people - and we really did get down to basics! Even showed one lady how to remove her card from the camera! She had never done that! The main questions they all asked was how to resize for email and how to remove red eye (a problem with p&s digis!)

Between them there were nearly five or so different programmes (mainly from the camera of scanner or printer manufacturer) and we explored them all! Plus photoshop elements (only up to version 2!)

One other programme - a free download - which does the job of resizing for many - is irfanview - from www.irfanview.com - and works really well for many folk

You could add that one to the list too

Cheers

Tue Mar 28, 09:05:00 pm GMT+12  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Tony,

Another free program you might like to add to your list is PhotoFiltre.
www.photofiltre.com.
A great little program, set up along the lines of Photoshop but, I think, simpler to use. Quite a few plug ins and filters available on the site too.

regards

Dion

Wed Mar 29, 09:55:00 pm GMT+12  
Blogger fricc said...

Have you tried LightZone?

It is a lot easier, faster and more powerful than PhotoShop for your digital photography needs.

http://www.lightcrafts.com

see it in action at:

http://web.mac.com/fabio.riccardi/iWeb/Site/Blog/Blog.html

Fri Mar 31, 04:29:00 am GMT+12  
Blogger fricc said...

Have you tried LightZone?

It is a lot easier, faster and more powerful than PhotoShop for your digital photography needs.

http://www.lightcrafts.com

see it in action at:

http://web.mac.com/fabio.riccardi/iWeb/Site/Blog/Blog.html

Fri Mar 31, 04:29:00 am GMT+12  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

What about Rawshooter as an altenaitive? you've got both a few and a more powerful and fuller funcyioning pro version at a fraction of the price and it feels pretty good to use.

John

Sun Apr 02, 11:08:00 pm GMT+12  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Hi There

A really great program to use for Digitial, is Microsoft Digital Imaging Suite Pro. But Warning, dont get confused with Digital Image standard edition, which is not so good. It does everything, including downloading, cataloguing and also prompting you for for Archives.
Cheers

Urszula

Tue Apr 18, 04:08:00 pm GMT+12  

Post a Comment

<< Home